Too Many Bones Review: Harnessing the Power of Dice and Strategy

Updated:

When was the last time you dared to venture into the wild lands of fantasy, drenched in intrigue, pulsating with danger and glittering with the promise of treasure? Welcome to our Too Many Bones review, a game that propels you into the heart of such an adventure, begging the question – can there ever really be too many bones?

It’s been a whirlwind journey with this game for me, starting from the moment it caught my eye at a local board game store. As a seasoned board game enthusiast, I felt an irresistible pull towards its uniqueness and the promise of strategic complexity hidden beneath its beautifully crafted components. Ever since that moment of discovery, Too Many Bones has been a prominent feature on my gaming table, unraveling a fresh narrative tapestry with every playthrough.

Too Many Bones Review

It seems a poignant time to delve into the world of Too Many Bones and share this review, considering the surge in its popularity amongst the gaming community. This game seems to be gradually turning into a cult classic, its allure being whispered among gaming circles, catching the attention of seasoned strategists and narrative lovers alike. Yet, there is still a sense that this gem remains underappreciated, overshadowed by some of the behemoth titles in the board game world.

This Too Many Bones review aims to shed light on this hidden treasure, exploring the game’s multifaceted dimensions, from the intricate mechanics and luxurious components to the immersive gameplay experience. So, prepare yourself for an expedition into the wild unknown, but beware! Here be dragons, or rather, tyrants, and the path is strewn with… you guessed it, too many bones.

I should caution you, though – I have found that Too Many Bones is not a game for everyone. Its depth and complexity might prove daunting to some, and the journey is long and fraught with challenges. But for those with the spirit of a Gearloc, this game promises a rich and rewarding experience unlike any other. This is not the final judgment on the game, but it gives you a glimpse of the adventure that lies ahead. Buckle up, fellow adventurers, we’re in for a wild ride!

Just The Facts

Key FactDetails
Game TitleToo Many Bones
DesignerAdam and Josh J. Carlson
PublisherChip Theory Games
ThemeFantasy Adventure
GenreDice Building RPG
Target AudienceAdvanced Gamers
Age Range12+
Number of Players1-4
Game Duration60-120 minutes
Complexity LevelHigh
Game ObjectiveOvercome the tyrant
ReplayabilityHigh
Difficulty LevelHigh
Similar GamesGloomhaven, Mage Knight
AwardsGolden Geek Best Solo Game (2017)
Release Date2017

Game Overview

Immersing yourself into the world of Too Many Bones is like stepping into an enchanted portal that leads to a land bustling with danger, adventure, and of course, the delightful allure of treasure. When you play this game, you become a Gearloc, a brave yet diminutive creature who is as deft in handling weapons as he is crafty in navigating through treacherous terrains and precarious situations.

The goal? Well, it’s a valiant one: to journey through the wild, unforgiving lands, overcome a series of relentless challenges, and ultimately face-off against the ominous tyrant, a boss so formidable that even the bravest hearts might falter. But fret not, this game is as much about the journey as it is about the destination. And each step you take, each decision you make, weaves an intricate tapestry of stories that make every gameplay session unique, intense, and utterly memorable.

But beware, Too Many Bones is not for the faint-hearted or the casually curious. With its deep strategy, multifaceted mechanics, and high-stakes gameplay, it is a game aimed squarely at the seasoned gamer – those who love the thrill of complex problem-solving, the anticipation of unearthing character abilities, and the intense satisfaction of overcoming seemingly insurmountable challenges.

Components and Artwork

If there’s one thing that’s immediately evident about Too Many Bones, it’s the sheer extravagance of its components. The game boasts an assortment of premium poker chips that serve as character and enemy tokens, lending a unique tactile experience that you’d be hard-pressed to find in most board games. There’s also a plenitude of custom dice, each with their unique abilities and effects, that makes the character progression mechanic a rich and diverse experience.

But the luxurious quality of components isn’t just limited to the poker chips and dice. The player mats, for instance, are made from a neoprene material akin to mousepads. This provides a sense of robustness, allowing the mats to lay flat while also providing a delightful surface for rolling dice.

Then there’s the artwork. The style adopted in Too Many Bones is an intriguing blend of whimsical and gritty, a reflection of the narrative dichotomy that runs at the heart of the game. The Gearlocs look as if they’ve stepped out from the pages of a twisted fairy tale, while the world around them mirrors this aesthetic with its intriguing mix of fantasy and adventure elements. This harmony between the artwork and the narrative theme is what lends the game its immersive and captivating atmosphere.

Gameplay Experience

The setup phase in Too Many Bones is reminiscent of embarking on an epic adventure. Each player steps into the role of a Gearloc, arms themselves with their character mat and a unique pool of dice. From there, it’s a day-by-day march towards the tyrant. Each day, players can choose to rest or venture out into a perilous encounter, each fraught with dangers and opportunities.

The gameplay is packed with strategic depth and complexity. Players need to carefully manage their limited resources, optimize their character’s abilities, and adapt to the ever-evolving scenarios. The rules can seem daunting initially, with several mechanics at play, and some that change as the game progresses.

Yet, within this intricate complexity, there’s an intricate balance of strategy, chance, and player interaction. It’s the melding of these elements that gives the game its unique flavor. With each game, you’re urged to experiment with different strategies, leading to an innovative and engaging play experience.

Theme and Immersion

The integration of theme into the gameplay mechanics of Too Many Bones is nothing short of impressive. Each Gearloc, each enemy, each dice roll, each encounter, seems to effortlessly blend into the overarching narrative theme of the game. This harmonious integration creates an immersive atmosphere that draws players in, compelling them to invest in their Gearlocs’ story.

However, the brilliance of Too Many Bones lies in its capacity to generate a unique narrative with each game session. While the overarching theme remains constant, the individual elements, like the choice of Gearlocs, encounters, and the final tyrant, create a different story each time. This inherent variability enhances the replayability and keeps the game fresh and exciting.

The narrative theme is also enriched by the gorgeous artwork, with the whimsical yet gritty style matching perfectly with the fantastical setting. Combined with the tactile delight of handling the premium components, Too Many Bones offers a truly immersive gaming experience.

Replayability

With Too Many Bones, replayability isn’t just an additional feature; it’s part of the game’s core design. Each game offers a new adventure, with different Gearlocs, different day-to-day encounters, and different tyrants to challenge. This variability keeps the game fresh and encourages players to return to the game, eager to explore new strategies and experience new adventures.

Moreover, the game includes several expansions, each introducing new Gearlocs, new encounters, and even new mechanics. These expansions, when added to the base game, significantly enhance the replayability, offering an even wider array of narratives and experiences.

The strategic depth and the unpredictability of the dice rolls also contribute to the replayability. The game’s mechanics offer countless strategic possibilities, and each dice roll can alter the course of the game, keeping players on their toes and creating a unique game experience with each playthrough.

Player Interaction and Engagement

One of the strengths of Too Many Bones is its focus on player interaction. From planning the day’s activity to engaging in battle against enemies, players are constantly involved and engaged in the game’s progress. Cooperation is encouraged, as joint strategy often leads to victory. However, there is also room for competition, as players aim to outdo each other in combat.

The game also creates an interesting social dynamic as players navigate through the game’s narrative. Every decision has consequences, and these consequences often affect all players, leading to intense discussions and debates. This focus on player interaction keeps the game engaging and ensures players are invested in the game from start to finish.

Learning Curve and Accessibility

Too Many Bones is undoubtedly a complex game. The rules are intricate, and the mechanics are multifaceted. As a result, the game has a steep learning curve. New players may need a few games to fully grasp the rules and mechanics. However, the game includes a comprehensive rulebook, and several player aids and online tutorials are available to aid the learning process.

While its complexity might deter casual gamers or younger players, Too Many Bones is an excellent fit for seasoned gamers who relish the challenge of mastering complex game mechanics. With patience and perseverance, players can uncover the depth and nuances of the game, leading to a rewarding and satisfying gaming experience.

Expansions

Too Many Bones has several expansions, each one adding more depth and variety to the game. Among them are:

  • Undertow: Introduces a new storyline, two new Gearlocs, and new encounters.
  • Age of Tyranny: Adds a campaign mode to the game, enhancing the narrative aspect of “Too Many Bones”.
  • 40 Days in Daelore: More encounters, more tyrants, and even a new Gearloc.

Each expansion adds something unique, and whether you’re looking for more story, more variety, or just more Too Many Bones, there’s an expansion to suit your needs.

Comparison to Similar Games

Too Many Bones stands in a unique position among its peers in the genre. Its combination of deep strategy, dice-building mechanics, and unique components set it apart from other adventure games. For example, games like Gloomhaven offer a similar adventure experience but lack the unique components and dice mechanics. On the other hand, Mage Knight, known for its complex decision-making, doesn’t offer the same tactile experience provided by Too Many Bones.

What sets Too Many Bones apart is its unique blend of character progression and probability management. It takes the best elements from its peers – the adventure of Gloomhaven and the complex decision-making of Mage Knight – and adds its unique flavor. If you’re a fan of these games, and looking for a new challenge, Too Many Bones might be the perfect fit for you.

Pros and Cons

Pros

  1. Unique Dice Building Mechanic: Too Many Bones stands out with its unique dice-building mechanic. Each character, or Gearloc, has a pool of custom dice that they build and improve upon throughout the game. This element offers a high level of customization and makes each playthrough feel fresh and engaging.
  2. High Replayability: The game shines in its replayability, due to the large variety of Gearlocs, encounters, and tyrants. Each game session presents a new combination of elements, which results in a unique narrative and strategic challenges.
  3. Premium Components: The quality of the game components is a significant strength. The poker chip health trackers, neoprene mats, and custom dice all contribute to a premium, tactile gaming experience.
  4. Deep Strategic Gameplay: The blend of strategy and chance makes every decision critical and gameplay deeply engaging. This strategic depth, coupled with the unpredictability of dice rolls, offers a complex and satisfying gaming experience.
  5. Strong Theme Integration: The narrative theme of the game is well executed and thoroughly integrated into the gameplay. This integration creates a compelling and immersive gaming experience.

Cons

  1. Steep Learning Curve: The complexity of Too Many Bones can be a double-edged sword. While it offers deep strategic gameplay, it also results in a steep learning curve, which may be off-putting to some players, particularly those new to board gaming.
  2. Long Game Duration: Games of Too Many Bones can last up to two hours, which could be considered a drawback for players looking for a quick game. Planning and executing strategies takes time, which can extend game duration.
  3. Dependency on Luck: Despite the game’s deep strategic possibilities, there’s a significant element of luck involved in the dice rolls. Some players might find the level of chance disconcerting, especially when a poor roll can upset well-laid plans.
  4. Price Point: As a premium product, Too Many Bones comes with a premium price tag. While the quality of the components justifies the cost, it might still be a prohibitive factor for some players.
  5. Player Count Limitations: While the game can be played solo, the best experience is arguably with 2 to 3 players. With four players, the game can become a little unwieldy and the downtime between turns can increase.

Too Many Bones Review: Final Thoughts and Verdict

Too Many Bones is a complex but rewarding beast of a game. It’s a rich tapestry of decision-making, character progression, and adventure that keeps players engaged from start to finish. While the learning curve is steep, the reward for mastery is a deeply strategic and immersive game experience.

Overall, I would give Too Many Bones a solid 8.5 out of 10. It’s a must-have for fans of deep strategy and dice-building RPGs. Just be prepared for the challenging journey you’ll undertake when you step into the shoes of a Gearloc.

Want Your Own Copy?

Looking for Even More?


Too Many Bones Review FAQ

What is the player count for Too Many Bones?

Too Many Bones is a solo game at its core but is designed to accommodate up to 4 players. However, the gameplay is often considered best with 2 to 3 players, as with four players, the game can become somewhat unwieldy, and the downtime between turns can increase.

How long does a game of Too Many Bones typically last?

Depending on the players’ familiarity with the game and the complexity of the chosen tyrant, a game of Too Many Bones can last from 60 to 120 minutes or even more.

Is Too Many Bones suitable for beginners?

Due to its deep strategy, multifaceted mechanics, and high-stakes gameplay, Too Many Bones is considered more suitable for seasoned gamers. It does have a steep learning curve and may be challenging for new or casual players

How is the replayability of Too Many Bones?

Too Many Bones boasts high replayability due to the large variety of Gearlocs, encounters, and tyrants. Each game session presents a new combination of elements, which results in a unique narrative and strategic challenges. The addition of several expansions further enhances the replayability.

How does Too Many Bones compare to similar games in the genre?

Too Many Bones stands apart due to its unique blend of character progression and probability management, taking the best elements from its peers like the adventure of Gloomhaven and the complex decision-making of Mage Knight, and adding its unique flavor.

Are there expansions available for Too Many Bones?

Yes, there are several expansions for Too Many Bones, including Undertow, Age of Tyranny, and 40 Days in Daelore. Each expansion adds unique features and enhances the game’s depth and variety.

What is the price range for Too Many Bones?

As a premium product, Too Many Bones comes with a premium price tag. The exact cost can vary based on location and retailer, so it’s best to check with a trusted local or online board game store for the current price.

What makes Too Many Bones stand out?

Several elements make Too Many Bones stand out, including its unique dice-building mechanic, high replayability, premium components, deep strategic gameplay, and strong theme integration. It’s a rich blend of decision-making, character progression, and adventure.

What are some potential drawbacks of Too Many Bones?

Some potential drawbacks include its steep learning curve, long game duration, dependency on luck in dice rolls, its high price point, and potential player count limitations, particularly with four players.